Australian companies and employees consistently recognise the value of continuous training in career and industry progression. In the latest study conducted by Australian Bureau of Statistics, it was revealed that the percentage of people taking work-related training is gradually increasing every year. Summative and formative assessments are crucial in evaluation work-related training.
Progress cannot be measured by attending the training programmes alone. It is paramount that employees absorb and apply the knowledge they gain. Let’s delve into the difference between formative and summative assessments and explore how each can contribute to a successful training programme.
What is the Difference Between Formative and Summative Assessment?
Understanding the difference between formative and summative assessments is essential in any training strategy. Formative assessment is ongoing, often informal, and designed to provide continuous feedback that helps improve learning. It occurs during the training process and supports skill acquisition by identifying areas for improvement. In contrast, summative assessment evaluates learners’ knowledge after a training session. It’s often more formal and structured, measuring the results and verifying that learning objectives were met.
Formative v Summative Assessment Examples
To illustrate formative versus summative assessment, let’s consider a scenario in corporate sales training.
- Formative Assessment Example: A sales trainer provides role-play scenarios where trainees engage in mock client conversations. The trainer observes and gives immediate feedback, highlighting areas for improvement, such as tone, questioning techniques, or closing strategies. This formative assessment helps trainees refine their skills in real time, ensuring they are better prepared before facing real clients.
- Summative Assessment Example: At the end of the training programme, trainees take a final assessment, such as a written test or a formal evaluation of a simulated sales pitch. Here, the objective is to evaluate overall knowledge retention and determine if trainees are ready to apply these skills on the job.
Comparing Formative vs. Summative Assessment in Corporate Training
Purpose and Goals
The primary goal of formative assessment is to support learning by identifying strengths and areas for improvement. It is a diagnostic tool that enables trainers to adjust and guide learners. Corporate training might involve regular quizzes, one-on-one feedback sessions, or peer discussions.
Summative assessments measure and confirm knowledge after training completion. They help organisations determine if learning objectives were achieved and if employees can demonstrate the required skills in a real-world context. Summative assessments might include final exams, certifications, or skill demonstrations.
Timing and Frequency
Formative Assessments are frequent and ongoing, occurring at various points during the training process. They allow trainers to make real-time adjustments to improve outcomes. Summative Assessments are conducted at the end of a training programme or module, with the final score or result determining if learning targets were met.
Feedback Mechanism
With formative assessments, feedback is immediate and continuous, aimed at improving performance throughout the training. For example, feedback on a role-play session allows trainees to make adjustments and try again, helping them refine their skills progressively.
In summative assessments, feedback often comes at the end and is typically more formal. It’s generally used for record-keeping or to make high-stakes decisions, such as whether an employee advances to the next level of training or earns certification.
Adaptability and Responsiveness
Formative assessments offer adaptability, allowing trainers to respond to each learner’s needs. In corporate settings, formative assessment tools like quizzes or reflection exercises can reveal trends in understanding and uncover areas requiring further instruction.
Summative assessments tend to be fixed, with less room for modification. They serve as a final check of knowledge or skills and are often tied to completing a course or curriculum.
When to Apply Formative vs. Summative Assessments in Corporate Training
Formative Assessments are beneficial when the goal is to support skill development over time. They’re ideal for new hires undergoing onboarding, as these assessments allow trainers to provide ongoing feedback, identify misunderstandings early, and foster a growth mindset. They’re also well-suited for training scenarios involving soft skills, such as leadership development or customer service, where continual improvement is crucial.
Summative Assessments, on the other hand, are beneficial in situations where conclusive verification of knowledge or skills is essential. For example, they’re commonly used in compliance training to ensure all employees meet regulatory standards. They’re also useful in technical training, where a final test can confirm that employees have the necessary competencies to handle critical tasks.
Conclusion
In the debate of formative vs summative assessment, it’s clear that both approaches are valuable and play distinct roles in corporate training. Formative assessments support learning progression, allowing trainees to build confidence and refine skills. Summative assessments, in contrast, provide a concrete measure of learning achievements, verifying readiness and certifying knowledge when needed.
A balanced approach that leverages formative and summative assessments enables organisations to foster continuous learning while validating competencies. By understanding each’s strengths and limitations, trainers can create more effective learning experiences, ensuring that employees are supported during their development journey and ready to perform confidently in their roles.
Combine summative and formative assessments in your training programme with eSkilled LMS. Build your own virtual training course, monitor your employees’ progress, and stay organised with an LMS that caters to modern workplaces. Book a demo today!
